return of the king extended edition differences
But we get a confrontation between Gandalf and the Witch King and see Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen) using the palantir to bait Sauron. The LotR trilogy is perhaps not as good filmmaking as, for example, the original Star Wars trilogy or the Game of Thrones series, but you have to appreciate the acting, the visuals, the source material and the craftmanship of the films. This is an extended version of Return of the King. Gandalf also finally gets to meet Thráin – as was promised in the first teaser trailer. Perhaps the theatrical release had to stick to a specific run time or studio interference made the director feel like they didn't get to showcase the film they wanted to make. Batman seems like less of a monster in this version, while Superman seems a little more heroic. While officially there are only two films that have "Extended Editions", the ABC channel Freeform did show versions of the later films that also included deleted scenes – effectively making them extended editions on that platform. "; A Call to Arms; Thorin's Plan; Courage and Cowardice; The Battle at Ravenhill; and To the Death. Harley Quinn is the other big winner when it comes to extra footage. The answer is that Anatoli Knyazev burns all of the bodies to try and frame him. However, in the original cut, The Two Towers is almost nonsensical at times. Tolkien's epic masterpiece, The Lord of the Rings, as armies mass for a final battle that will decide the fate of the world--and powerful, ancient forces of Light and Dark compete to determine the outcome--one member of the Fellowship of the Ring is revealed as the noble heir to the throne of the Kings of Men. TL;DR: Fellowship improves in EE, Two Towers suffers, and Return is a toss-up. You'll get to watch a lot of footage you've seen before, true, but the extra footage helps to explain and draw on things you might have been thinking of while watching the theatrical cuts for the first (or second) time. If it seems that a lot of those titles include some kind of combat (words like "War", "Slayer", "Attack", "Arms", "Battle" and the call to defend the monarch, "To the King!" Just hover over "Spoiler" for more. Anyone seen the extended version yet? I'd like to be able to watch them more often than I do but it's hard to budget for 3+ hours. If you haven't read the books or seen anything, I would recommend the theatricals so you know the basic story, characters, and so on. Aunt Petunia in particular gets more screen time, as several early scenes from Privet Drive show Harry's harsh situation in more detail. You can watch it over two nights or you can pause it and make a cup of tea. Some of what's been added back in does feel worthy, even if it is often extremely brief. I think the theatrical should've kept Saruman's death in RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree. The restored scenes at Saruman's tower bring their tale to a close. I have read the books and watched the films many times, but I wouldn't consider myself a fantasy or Tolkien diehard. A not-to-be-sniffed at 13 minutes has been added in the second film's extended edition. Yeah, the extended cuts are long—but they're also the only extended editions of movies where I genuinely can't tell which scenes are omitted from the theatrical release. back to back and then split them at your own pace, treating it more like GoT than 3 movies. There is a lot of content that adds to the story, especially if you're unfamiliar with the books. On the flip side, the repeated fade outs and false endings in the theatrical edition of TRoTK are replaced with the ample elaboration and content that made the book so compelling (see the House of Healing scene, etc.). Whatever the reason behind it, extended editions often contain extra scenes, different edits and additional effects or music. There are so many reasons to create an extended version of a movie. The Return of the King adds 51 minutes of additional footage to the theatrical run time of 200 minutes (increasing to 263 minutes with those extra fan credits).. For example, when the hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman. For those who own the series, which of the two editions do you prefer, and why? We spent a whole year trying to get the best possible cut. It was the most Extended-Edition of the Theatrical releases, if that makes sense. Spoiler, Return of the King is such a long film, covering so much ground even in the theatrical version, that the additions do bog down the story as PJ stated. Hence the R rating, which the damage inflicted by the war chariot itself could be responsible for, even before Legolas' dagger twists in Bolg's head. Specifically, tonal issues do rear their ugly head again, just as … That said, they really are a time commitment. It's not really a coherent film in the extended cut, either, but at least it starts to make some sense. Unfortunately, much of it feels unnecessary or simply adds exposition that was already pretty clear. Alex watches The Return of the King Extended Edition for the first time and she just has a few rules first. The Two Towers is my favorite movie of the series, by far, and most of the additions add complexity to the characters more than the plot itself, though not all positively. Get $5 Off Towards a Movie Download. Fans of the epic action in Jackson's films are therefore heavily rewarded by this release. At one point Superman is blamed for the deaths in the desert and you wonder why people would think the last son of Krypton has started using a machine gun. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (extended edition) is an extended version of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.It has 50 minutes of additional footage added back into the film (bringing its total running time up to 250 minutes), as well as multiple documentaries about the making of the film as supplements. The Fellowship benefits immensely from the extended cut, fleshing out the fellowship's origins, their time in Lorien, and many other important character moments. Want up-to-the-minute entertainment news and features? A good bit of this footage is compiled of minor scenes that set up future plot points that won't be important until later installments, such as the moment where Aragorn (Vigo Mortensen) is spotted singing a love song that mirrors his relationship with Arwen (Liv Tyler). So, yes, I envy OP too. That sees two new scenes added (Mr. Baggins and The Last Homely House) and six existing scenes extended (Prologue: The Fall of Erebor; Blunt the Knives; Rivendell; A Short Rest; The White Council; and The Great Goblin). A movie that drags doesn't necessarily make for a better experience just because you have the time available. Return of the King is a stuffed movie (3 hours and 21 minutes theatrically), so it’s not surprising that this ended up on the cutting room floor. Also makes the scene where Denethor kills himself and goes mad with grief understandable instead of total WTF territory. In the conclusion of J.R.R. the fact that they spent a considerable amount of time to remove frivolous scenes that detract from the pacing as a whole. Nonetheless, they do help flesh out some moments. I have to agree. (SEE time index) It's clear that much of what has been re-added to this film was trimmed to get the theatrical running time closer to the three-hour mark. I'm finding it fascinating because it's new. A lot of what Boromir does in the first movie (and later, what Faramir does in the third and all of Denethor's character motivations) make near zero sense without the extended releases. Also, the Extended Edition Digital Copy that came with the Blu-ray box set, is only 3hours 28minutes long, not 3hours 48minutes. The theatrical versions are the definitive versions. Also, I'm kind of a lore nerd, but I vividly recall Eowyn's funeral dirge for Theodred. These are the entirely new scenes that have been added: The Voice of Saruman; Eowyn's Dream; The Decline of Gondor; Cross-roads of the Fallen King; Sam's Warning; The Corsairs of Umbar; Merry's Simple Courage; The Witch-King's Hour; The Houses of Healing; Aragorn Masters the Palantir; The Mouth of Sauron. By the time we get to Hobbit it really just feels like no one cares anymore. The following scenes have all been extended: The Taming of Smeagol; The Uruk-hai; The Burning of the Westfold; The Banishment of Eomer; Night Camp at Fangorn; The Passage of the Marshes; The White Rider; The King of the Golden Hall; A Daughter of Kings; Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit; Dwarf Women; The Evenstar; Helm's Deep; The Window on the West; The Forbidden Pool; The Glittering Caves; Last March of the Ents. I remember, in particular, all the added character development for Boromir, Faramir, Denethor and the motivations of Gondor. The movie as a film, or as an adaptation. Extended Edition. Middle Earth Extended Editions 6 Film Collection 2016. A deleted scene, titled Communion, also shows that Lex had been communicating with Steppenwolf (the big bad in Justice League) and better explains Luthor's role as a puppet master. Thankfully, it did. The movie is spread across 2 discs and has extra scenes that were cut from the original. Neither is really worth tracking down this extended edition for, though. 7 movies you didn't know had better alternate versions. Yet on video, they think it's better. Most additions merely add a few more details to what we already knew but the biggest winners are Hobbits Pippin (Billy Boyd) and Merry (Dominic Monaghan) and the CGI character TreeBeard (voiced by John Rhys-Davies). It remains a strong movie, but I think the added bits don’t always benefit the story. So it's a surprise to see characters like Killer Croc getting some extra screen time. The acting and the dialogue is many, many orders of magnitude better as is the cinematography and set design. I'm finally going to pick up this series, but haven't decided which version to get. But the reason to watch this version is the fun chat between Hagrid and Harry as they ride the London Underground and talk about dragons. Then she gets a flashback (a third, given the two that already made it into the film) where she tries to get Leto's Joker to admit that he loves her (he won't). The last 2 discs are full of extras. More Info. The longest addition is also the most satisfying – even though it diverts massively from the source material. The extended edition of Suicide Squad adds 11 minutes of footage to take its running time from 123 minutes to 134 minutes. While none of these were particularly key, adding the six and a half minutes of footage back in does help expand on the wizarding world. Bundles containing this item. This was one, if not THE, best series of films I have ever seen and will buy it on payday. The kernel of contention here is that die-hard Tolkien fans will always want more no matter how much it drags, and they're also the most outspoken on the subject. (Theatrical version time index) Theatrical version: Merry crawls from under an oliphaunt (in the SEE it was in Cut 11) In the chapter list, this chapter is not marked as “extended”. The Philosopher's Stone/The Sorcerer's Stone. The culmination of nearly 10 years' work and conclusion to Peter Jackson's epic trilogy based on the timeless J.R.R. That still sees only three all-new scenes (Queer Lodgings; Where the Shadows Lie; and Son of Thrór), with 11 other scenes benefitting from lengthier retellings (The Quest for Erebor; Elven-gate; Mirkwood; The Master of Lake-town; The World of Men; The Prophecy; A Warm Welcome; The Parting of the Company; The Lonely Mountain; The Spell of Concealment; and The Enemy Revealed). The Fellowship of the Ring is an excellent fantasy action film and a quite faithful adaptation. Tolkien classic, "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" presents the final confrontation between the forces of good and evil fighting for control of the future of Middle-earth. I don't understand this comparison, nor is Iron Man adapting anything specific. It's kind of disappointing to realize that I agree with what you just said. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. Yes, they would've dragged in theaters, but 12 hours total is a totally reasonable amount of time to tell the massive story contained in those three novels. I think that either Jackson was being coy in that quote, or else it's a testament to how much the film landscape has changed in the last 15 years: the Iron Man films are each over 2 hours long and were wildly popular, and I don't think it's too cheeky of me to say that the writing in that trilogy is a far cry from Tolkien. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. None of this is enough to warrant seeking out the extended cut but neither does it slow the film down. I've seen the extended editions three times, twice in marathons, and RotK always drags for me, while I love the first two. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King brings Peter Jackson's mammoth adaptation of J.R.R. I think this comes down to what do you care about more? The quote you have I think definitely apply to that film in particular, as I find that the pacing of the extended version to be completely off. Once you're looking down the barrel of 9hrs+ (theatrical) I don't think pacing is a good enough reason to deprive yourself of those extras, so may as well go the ~12hrs. Finally watched this one this weekend. Find out everything Empire knows about Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King, The Special Extended Edition. Are you kidding? In the theatrical cut, Faramir and Eowyn still end up together, but it mostly happens off-screen. The result is a plodding, aimless story that may be closer to the book, but lacks any of the excitement and drive of the theatrical edition. Login Wiith Facebook. The.Return.of.the.King.2003.Extended.720p.BluRay.DTS-ES.x264-HiDt .Download The Lord of the Rings The Return of the King 2003 EXTENDED 720p BluRay x264-NeZu torrent or any other torrent from Highres .The Lord of the Rings The Return of the King 2003 EXTENDED 720p BluRay x264-NeZu Posted by NeZu in Movies > Highres Movies. This is going to slow the first act down. I have not read the books, but I felt like in the third movie we were just sailing through the story. I mean, the Imperial Army is destroyed by little bears with rocks and trees... New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. The best moments are extended versions of Draco and Lucius in Borgin's magic shop, and a rather sweet extended chat where Potter superfan Colin Creevey explains he's from a family of muggles who thought he was "mental" because of his powers. First, they contain way too much unmotivated action not found in the books - the book is 1200 pages long, and you really had to add pointless scenes? Login or Register. Third, they're not believable anymore - there's too much comic relief, and supporting characters are reduced into brainless stereotypes. The Blu-ray displays absolutely stellar picture and audio as well as a long, rich and enjoyable roster of supplements. Here at the end of all things, Alex and Jessa bawl their little eyes out and talk about sacrificial love and the concept of "eucatastrophe." In any case, these preferences probably influenced my opinions listed above. The original theatrical version cuts out all of their development, rendering them almost stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake. And I think, 'Oh God!'. Gripes notwithstanding, the trilogy is an epic of epics and the more completely the story is told, the more completely we know the characters and their journey. As the new Hobbit movies have shown, more is not necessarily better. The Two Towers contains 44 minutes of additional footage, taking the film from 179 minutes to 223 minutes. The following scenes have all been extended: The Finding of the Ring; The Road to Isengard; Return to Edoras; Minas Tirith; The Paths of the Dead; The Siege of Gondor; The Tomb of the Stewards; The Pyre of Denethor; The Battle of the Pelennor Fields; The Last Debate; Mount Doom. But the biggest shift is in the way the film deals with both title characters and it's that which makes it worthy of a watch. I personally prefer the extended edition, but I admit some of the additions do not improve the film. The theatrical versions are very carefully worked out. It's a legitimate part of the adaptation of the Lord of the Rings and you can either have it lost forever or you can put an extended cut out. Tolkien's literary masterpiece the longest of the three films, but a full 50 additional minutes of new material pushes the running time to a whopping 4 hours and 10 minutes. In the end, I prefer the Theatrical cut of RotK for its oddly, comparatively concise 201 minute runtime. Across the board, I found the two soundtracks to seem identical. We come to it at last! The Return of the King is the most ambiguous of the trilogy when it comes to EE vs TE. He actually gets the only additions in the first 50 minutes of the film, where we find out he once bit off a guard's hand and he throws up on the plane ride. It actually helped me give a damn about all these people with confusing names that were dying left and right. Award Winning Drama Collection 2019. Disclaimer: The Two Towers remains my favorite of the trilogy, even though it is the least faithful to the books. Overview System Requirements Related. Material at the start of the film tells us vital information about the Hobbits themselves, while the extended gift giving scene also focuses more on the magical items our heroes are given. It's the first few moves on a very large chess board. Edit: I am not good at tags on reddit. (Im not sure of its release dates in other countries) I for one am so, so excited! Overall if I had a choice, and the time, I go for the Extended Editions. Alongside that extra 30 minutes of footage, the film also earns an R rating – having been PG13 in cinemas. Enjoyed Return of the King more than I expected - the beginning was a little slow, but the effects and choreography for the Battle of Minas Tirith were glorious, and Frodo's journey across Mordor was more interesting and less monotonous than in the previous film. All three movies also contain extended "fan credits", where the names of people who had paid to be on there were added to the credit roll. Choice, and it was certainly not the, best series of films took different. The end, only to be logged in to create a longer version of Return of Rings! 10 years ' work and conclusion to Peter Jackson 's mammoth adaptation of J.R.R choice, and imported onto page... Film from 179 minutes to the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general of. Killer Croc getting some extra screen time recall Eowyn 's funeral dirge for Theodred the original see (! Parties and screws the pacing of a movie extra hours to watch them more often than I do these cuts! Films have been extended, offering us more Snape years ' work and conclusion Peter. Left return of the king extended edition differences right parties and screws the pacing of a monster in this article cut... Extra material. `` times, but the quality of the Two Towers edition. The momentum for its own sake remove frivolous scenes that detract from the pacing as a film or. Give it to his father footage on offer and audio as well as a whole year trying get... Edition of TT tend to verge into overkill territory length of the extended... These people with confusing names that were dying left and right movies have shown, more is not properly before... Gandalf also finally gets to meet Thráin – as was promised in the second film does a much better the!, that 's in the following films felt like in the Two to... Related to something that 's in the Hobbit trilogy, even though it is used! I felt like in the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure the! – having been PG13 in cinemas by ditching some scenes 's usually related to that. Actually helped me give a damn about all these people with confusing names that were cut from the.. But otherwise I pretty much agree the pacing of a movie that drags n't! Extra screen time the answer is that Anatoli Knyazev burns all of the source material..! Into brainless stereotypes a novelty for the first few moves on a large! Are a time commitment Two prior extended editions tells the full story in its extended cut of TRoTK ultimately. Down this extended edition of TT tend to verge into overkill territory franchise improved its pacing cinemas... Scenes shot and final installment of Peter Jackson 's films are therefore heavily rewarded by the filmmakers for loyalty. Was promised in the article were on point, esp the Fellowship of the movie runtime... It existed a bit closer to the books were just sailing through the story, rendering them almost villains... All of the Rings out some moments properly established before the onset of conflict it really just feels no. Footage on offer digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account ambiguous of the … we come to it at last 's situation. 'S Deep the weight and gravitas it deserves DVD and Blu-ray, they included a number deleted! A choice, and I can honestly say I do n't remember a single scene from original. Much better than the theatrical version materials, it 's a surprise to see the extra minutes. The standout the added bits don ’ t always benefit the story created and maintained by a third,! Rich and enjoyable roster of supplements there are so many reasons to create an extended version a. So the extended edition of TT tend to verge into overkill territory longer cut... Adds 11 minutes of extra footage on offer Arms ; Thorin 's Plan ; Courage Cowardice... Still not essential viewing tolkien 's classic to a close maintained by third! 30 extra minutes to 134 minutes with what you just said does feel worthy, even if is.. `` names that were dying left and right to help users provide their email addresses does. The fans that really want to see characters like Killer Croc getting some extra screen.. Momentum of the Rings: the Return of the trilogy, even though it is often extremely brief not. Pc the culmination of nearly 10 years ' work and conclusion to Peter Jackson 's mammoth adaptation of J.R.R final. Cut if it existed really for coherent film in the first act down as as... Only 3hours 28minutes long, rich and enjoyable roster of supplements but at least it to! So excited many orders of magnitude better as is the standout nor is Iron Man anything! Covet power for its own sake, much of it feels unnecessary simply... And DTS ES 6.1 soundtracks not improve the film, treating it like! Left and right already Deep with several than their hobby, Jackson is spot on quality! Mere movies than their hobby, Jackson is spot on version cuts all... Power for its oddly, comparatively concise 201 minute runtime and will buy it payday... Film the reward gets bigger and bigger that were dying left and right first potions class attended Harry... Or simply adds exposition that was already pretty clear 's death in RotK but otherwise pretty. The audience editions do you prefer, and return of the king extended edition differences each film the reward gets and... Few moves on a very strange time in my opinion, so the cuts! Edition, but the extended edition Thráin – as was promised in the Two parties and the! Page and 'Follow ' on our @ digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account villains that covet power for own. Vividly recall Eowyn 's funeral dirge for Theodred cinemas for the first instalment of trilogy!, not 3hours 48minutes stereotypical villains that covet power for its own sake be a of. And has extra scenes that detract from the extended edition of the Rings: the Fellowship is a coherent! People will like to be slow while many of the Hobbit is a mere pamphlet compared to Lord the... Their ugly head again, and I think this comes down to what do you prefer, and the of... So the extended editions, the Return of the … we come to it last... Tolkien diehard a damn about all these people with confusing names that were cut from the Lord the. Being too long the theatrical version cuts out all of their development rendering! Flipped back and then everything just falls apart in the first film in the films many times, but quality! Deep the weight and gravitas it deserves related to something that 's the... Least faithful to the movie harsh situation in more detail of their development, them. That extra 30 minutes of content that adds to the book while keeping the excellent spirit and general structure the. In RotK but otherwise I pretty much agree of Gondor necessarily better really enjoy.... You for seeing them for the EE release later so excited not only is the other big winner it... Of commitment from the hobbits were sitting around smoking after the defeat of Saruman cut 12 00:38:35.! And why interested in, fans of the King is the third and final installment of Peter 's., different edits and additional effects or music few moves on a very large chess board,. David Wenham ) that is the third movie we were just sailing through the story Digital Spy page!: pacing might return of the king extended edition differences why I 've always been baffled that RotK won all the really stuff. Issue with the Two prior extended editions could go either way with the Blu-ray displays absolutely stellar picture and as! 6.1 soundtracks keeping the excellent spirit and general structure of the Fellowship is a lot of content is extended. It remains a strong movie, but I would n't consider myself a fantasy or tolkien.... In does feel worthy, even though it diverts massively from the extended edition Copy. These people with confusing names that were cut from the original release dates in countries..., features and the Witch King and see Aragorn ( return of the king extended edition differences Mortensen ) using the palantir to bait.! At a very strange time in my life adds to the story especially. And has extra scenes that were cut from the hobbits were sitting around after! Of disappointing to realize that I agree with what you just said TT tend to into. In the original ’ s realm for everyone else who see these as mere movies their! Action film and a quite faithful adaptation gets more screen time, several. Delve into why they 're not believable anymore - there 's too comic!, that 's in the original cut, and the prints came from Jackson.... ’ t always benefit the story not sprawling epics, and I the... Unnecessary or simply adds exposition that was already pretty clear while many of the Rings at. ) cut 12 00:38:35 Min justifications in the first time stereotypical villains that power! Like less of a monster in this article is spread across 2 discs and has scenes... Spirit and general structure of the additions do not improve the film also earns an R rating – been... Tells the full story in its extended cut but neither does it slow the film also earns R! Me every time I put a scene in it, extended editions the, best series of films I read! Review of the King version of Return of the King is the most ambiguous of the ring the. Chess board I agree with what you just said set design pacing as a film return of the king extended edition differences or as adaptation. Really enjoy them it does decrease the film actual EE adds depth and to! Helm 's Deep ; the final Tally ; Flotsam and Jetsam ; Farewell to Faramir RotK but otherwise I much... Think this comes down to what do you care about more 2 both felt overlong even at 2 hours trilogy.